1031
Tax Exchange
Thinking
of selling your property? Let us show you how a 1031 exchange
may help you. 1031 your property to anywhere in the country
- even defer your capital gains and depreciation recapture tax!
We have helped many clients with 1031 exchanges. How far can 1031
take you? The sky's the limit!
Call
us at 877-873-3400 today.
The
Tax Deferred Exchange has become the tool of choice for Real Estate
investors who wish to defer taxes on both capital gains and depreciation
when a property is sold. Because the goal of most investors is
to make a profit, the payment of taxes can seriously dilute an
otherwise good return on an investment. The tax deferred exchange
has been part of the tax code since 1921, but it has become popular
only in the last decade due to changes in the tax code that have
made the process both easier to understand and more practical
to use. Real Estate professionals doing business in the 90's may
well find that an Exchange transaction will find them before they
feel knowledgeable enough to create one on their own. This information
was written for people who are not familiar with tax deferred
Exchanges and has been gleaned from the authors practical experience
in structuring and closing thousands of tax deferred Exchanges
over the last twenty years. Like most people, I learn a new subject
more easily if it is presented in plain English. This is my attempt
to do that for you.
Overview
Basic Rules
The Role of the Qualified
Intermediary
Exchange Documents
Earnest Money Contract
Exchange Agreement
Assignment Agreement
Exchange
Property Identification
Rules
Types of Exchanges
How to Make a Tax Deferred
Exchange
Overview
Beginning in the early 1920's, the Federal Tax Code has allowed
owners of real estate to defer taxes on the sale of property held
for business or investment by using the rules contained in what
is now Section 1031 of the Federal Tax Code. The Exchange
process can defer taxes on both capital gain and depreciation.
Currently, forty-eight of the fifty states have recognized the
1031 Exchange as being applicable to deferral of State taxes as
well. In the case of Oregon and South Carolina, the property received
in an Exchange must be located in the same state to qualify for
State tax deferral. It has been estimated that from 30 to 40 percent
of all real estate sales involve properties that would qualify
for Exchange treatment but because most property owners are not
familiar with the process, it is not used with the frequency that
it should be. The Tax Reform Act of 1986 eliminated preferential
treatment of long term capital gain and made the deferral of taxes
an integral part of good investment strategies. Prior to 1986,
40% of gains were subject to tax, now, however, 100% of gains
are subject to tax at Federal rates of up to 20%. Depreciation
taken is taxed at 25 %. State income taxes, if applicable, would
further add to the tax burden. Many property owners have concluded
that selling appreciated real estate is economically impractical
unless the Exchange process is utilized.
The basic requirements of an Exchange are relatively
simple. The investor (Exchanger) first finds someone to buy his
property, and beginning from the day the sale closes, the Exchanger
has a maximum of 180 days to purchase one or more properties to
replace what was sold. Replacement property must be identified
in writing within 45 days of the closing of the old property.
In at least one respect, the Tax Deferred Exchange is similar
to the old rules (prior to May 1997) that applied to the rollover
of gain from the sale of a primary residence in that the property
purchased must equal or exceed the adjusted sales price ( sale
price less closing costs) of the property sold. If a less costly
property were purchased, taxes are owed on the difference in cost.
One major interesting feature of an Exchange is that all of the
equity from the sale of the "old property" must be reinvested
in the "new property" and equity that remains unspent becomes
taxable. In addition, the use of an arms length third party who
is called a 'Qualified Intermediary' to facilitate an Exchange
transaction has been mandated by the Federal Tax Code since 1991.
Basic
Rules
During the last 70 years, the Exchange process has been referred
to by different names such as Like Kind Exchange, Starker Trust
or Exchange, Deferred or Delayed Exchange, Simultaneous or Concurrent
Exchange, Reverse Exchange, Alderson Exchange, Baird Exchange,
Two, Three, or Four Party Exchange, and so on. Regardless of what
they are called, every Exchange must conform to the same rules
found in Section 1031 of the Federal Tax Code. The following is
a summary of basic Exchange rules that apply to all Tax Deferred
Exchanges. In most cases the rules are very specific and must
be closely adhered to in the event that an Exchange is audited
by the IRS. Breaking rules invites a "disallowed" Exchange which
is the
same as not having done one at all. Interpretation of the rules
is often done by reviewing court cases that have set legal precedent
and Revenue or Letter rulings which are written opinions by the
IRS in response to questions submitted by taxpayers regarding
a proposed Exchange transaction.
The
Role of The Qualified Intermediary
The
Qualified Intermediary ... In 1991, Section 1031 of the Tax Code
was modified to include the use of a "Qualified intermediary"
to facilitate a Tax Deferred Exchange. The Qualified Intermediary
is defined as a person who is not related to the taxpayer and
who does not fulfill a role as the taxpayer's accountant, attorney,
or real estate broker, family member, employee, employer or other
related party. One of the most critical elements of the exchange
process is that the taxpayer may not receive or control any of
the cash proceeds resulting from the sale of his property. The
code refers to the Qualified Intermediary as a "Safe Harbor" in
the sense that the Intermediary will be the party that will receive
the cash proceeds from the sale of the taxpayer's property instead
of the taxpayer himself. The Intermediary will hold the proceeds
in a qualified escrow or "trust" account until such time as the
taxpayer purchases a replacement property. The essential functions
of the Intermediary are as follows...
1.
Consultation with the taxpayer to determine the feasibility of
an Exchange based on the estimated tax liability on the proposed
sale of a property.
2.
Structuring an Exchange format to achieve the taxpayer's investment
goals while meeting the Tax Code guidelines for minimizing or
completely eliminating tax liabilities on the proposed transaction.
Currently there are at least five available Exchange formats.
They are: 1. Delayed or Deferred Exchange in which the replacement
property is acquired up to 180 days after the relinquished property
closes. This is the most popular format. 2. A Simultaneous Exchange
occurs when both properties close on the same day. 3. The Reverse
Exchange allows for the closing of the replacement property before
the relinquished property is closed. 4. Improvement Exchanges
utilize a portion of the proceeds from the relinquished property
to
acquire a replacement property and the balance of the proceeds
to construct improvements on the property. 5. A Clearinghouse
Exchange involves multiple parties and multiple properties, The
Intermediary takes possession of all properties and then distributes
them to the appropriate parties at the conclusion of the Exchange,
Establishing the proper Exchange format is critical to ensuring
a defensible exchange should the client be audited by the IRS.
3.
Document Preparation is important to create a paper trail that
will characterize the transfer of an investment property as a
Tax Deferred Exchange as opposed to a taxable sale. Technically
accurate Exchange documents are created by the Qualified Intermediary
for this purpose and are specially designed for each Exchange
format. Closing instructions are created that conform to the Exchange
format and provide a written narrative of the transaction that
will demonstrate compliance with the requirements found in the
code.
4.
Closing Coordination is vital to ensure that pertinent Exchange
documents are signed by the proper parties in the required sequence
and that the taxpayer is never seen to be in control or receipt
of sale proceeds during the Exchange process. The doctrine pertaining
to actual or constructive receipt of Exchange proceeds by the
taxpayer is central to a valid exchange.
Closings
are monitored by the Qualified Intermediary to ensure that deposits,
option moneys, closing costs, fix up expenses, rehabilitation
costs, and other disbursements that occur at closing are handled
in such a way that they will not cause the Exchange to be disallowed
under audit due to constructive receipt of Exchange proceeds
5.
Audit Preparedness is of central importance to all Exchangers.
A Qualified Intermediary should maintain a Master Exchange File
containing all of the closing documents that relate to the Exchange
so that the taxpayer will be able to demonstrate compliance with
the provisions of the tax code should he ever be audited by the
IRS.
Exchange
Documents
Even the best laid plans for tax deferral hinge on the creation
and execution of paperwork that may be at some point be scrutinized
by the IRS. Exchange documents, deeds and closing statements are
routinely used by tax prepares to defend audits. Exchange
documentation that clearly demonstrates both the intent to Exchange
and strict compliance with Exchange rules will help to prevent
an Exchange from being disallowed at audit. For example, deeds
will help to identify closing dates on both old and new properties.
Closing statements will show property values and closing costs
and more importantly, "where the money
went' at closing, and Exchange documents give validity to the
whole process.
Earnest
Money Contract
The Earnest money contract will begin the paper trail that will
help to distinguish a transaction as a Tax Deferred Exchange.
In addition, the Contract will contain useful information as to
how the Exchange should be structured. Here are a few of the more
common things that need to be addressed.
1.
The Exchange Clause... Every Earnest Money Contract that is written
for an Exchange should contain an 'Exchange Clause. Here's what
one looks like:
For property Being Sold
SALE
OF THE SUBJECT PROPERTY IS PART OF A SECTION 1031 TAX DEFERRED
EXCHANGE. THE BUYER AGREES TO AN ASSIGNMENT OF THE SELLERS INTEREST
IN THIS CONTRACT TO A QUALIFIED INTERMEDIARY TO EFFECT SAID EXCHANGE.
NO ADDITIONAL COST OR LIABILITY WILL BE INCURRED ON THE
PART OF THE BUYER.
For property Being Purchased
PURCHASE
OF THE SUBJECT PROPERTY IS PART OF A SECTION 1031 TAX DEFERRED
EXCHANGE. THE SELLER AGREES TO AN ASSIGNMENT OF THE
BUYERS INTEREST IN THIS CONTRACT TO A QUALIFIED INTERMEDIARY TO
EFFECT SAID EXCHANGE. NO ADDITIONAL COST OR LIABILITY WILL BE
INCURRED ON THE PART OF THE SELLER.
Some of these clauses can be a lot longer and more elaborately
crafted, but they all accomplish the same two things:
A.
Establish the clients intent to make a Tax Deferred Exchange as
opposed to a taxable sale. The IRS likes to see the Exchange Clause
because the Earnest Money Contract is one of the documents that
they will be looking at to determine if the transaction qualifies
as an Exchange. To them, the demonstration of an intent to Exchange
is important.
B.
It's a good idea to let the Buyer (or Seller) know early on in
the transaction that there's something a little different going
on in the transaction. Most Buyers don't have a clue what an Exchange
is, and it's a good idea to get their questions answered at the
time the offer is tendered rather than at closing when other issues
may be causing a lot of stress. Sometimes an Agent will not put
the Clause in the body of the Contract but will include it in
an addendum, a counter offer or an exhibit
2.
Identify The Exchanging Parties ... When property is owned by
more than one person, make sure who is utilizing the Exchange
Process and who is not. For example, it cannot be assumed that
a husband and wife who are both on title to the old property are
Exchanging into a new property together, in fact many people use
the Exchange process for the disposition of assets in a divorce.
One party may want to cash out and the other may want to Exchange
their portion of the sale proceeds into another piece of property.
On occasion, you will find several owners of the property doing
their own separate Exchanges simultaneously, and on the same piece
of real estate. The reason for this is that if they all use the
same Exchange "umbrella', and
one parties Exchange is audited by the IRS, then everyone's Exchange
is audited. If each party creates and documents his own Exchange
for his own fractional interest in the property, then each Exchange
stands on it's own merits at audit. Sometimes separate closing
statements are prepared that will reflect the value of each fractional
property interest being Exchanged and the fractional portion of
the closing costs that relate to it. Each party is trying to build
a clear and concise paper trail as to the tax ramifications of
his individual part of the transaction.
3.
Continuity of Title ... The taxpayer or entity that owned the
old property must be the same taxpayer or entity that acquires
the new property. The reason for this is that the IRS wants to
see the acquisition of the new property on the same parties tax
return that disposed of the old property. It is possible to add
a person to the title of the new property that is acquired in
the Exchange. This can be done without dire tax consequences as
long as the added party goes on title for a clearly defined fractional
interest that gives our Exchanger a remaining fractional interest
that has a corresponding value that is no less than the value
of what he sold.
4.
Identify Trusts, Corporations and Partnerships ... Contracts should
accurately reflect the party or entity as they appear on ownership
documents. Exchange documentation created by the Intermediary
must reflect the actual owner of the property, and if it doesn't,
it may destroy the Exchange. If the deed shows a partnership as
the owner or the property it becomes important to determine if
the sale of the property will result in the break up (also called
a 'Drop Down') of the partnership interests. If so, the Exchange
may not be valid. The tax code indicates that the Exchange of
"Partnership Interests" are not permitted. Partnerships, Trusts,
and Corporations can Exchange property but as a general rule they
must remain intact to do it. An exception may be property
owned by two or more parties or entities who are characterized
as "Tenants in Common". These owners may dissolve their
relationships and use the Tax Deferred Exchange to do it. Partnership
Exchanges must be carefully be structured to provide compliance
with the tax code.
5.
Option Money Paid...To the Exchanger prior to closing may or may
not be taxable. The crux of the issue is whether or not the Option
Money is going to be applied to the purchase price. If it isn’t,
it’s taxable no matter what it's used for. Option Money applied
to the purchase price is treated the same as earnest money. If
the Exchanger has the money under his control at closing, it is
taxable. If, however the money is forwarded to the Intermediary
at the closing then it can become tax deferred along with the
rest of the proceeds of the sale. Option Money that will be applied
to the purchase price needs to be delivered to the title company
prior to closing, and at closing, must be disbursed to the Intermediary.
Failure to do this will cause the Exchanger to pay taxes on the
Option Money.
6.
Seller Financing ... It must be determined prior to closing who
will be named as the beneficiary of the note. It could be the
Exchanger, in which case the note will be taxable to him, most
likely according to Installment Sale rules, or the beneficiary
could be the Intermediary if it is contemplated that the note
will be used to purchase the replacement property. The mechanics
of using notes to buy replacement property are complex but to
use a note in an Exchange, the beneficiary or payee must be the
Intermediary and the note must be used (usually by converting
it to cash) to purchase the replacement property. Once the closing
takes place, it's impossible to change the beneficiary of a note
from a tax point of view.
7.
Personal Property Included in the Transfer ... Personal Property
is not real property. The Tax Code says that real property can
only be Exchanged for other real property, and that any personal
property received in an Exchange will be taxable to the extent
that Exchange monies are used to pay for it. If you think about
it, most all real estate sales and purchases include some incidental
personal property whether it be a refrigerator, freestanding stove
or some other item not considered appurtenant to the real estate.
The sale of a business may include, as part of the sale price,
real estate, inventory, goodwill, fixtures and equipment, a covenant
not to compete and various licenses and permits. It is possible
to Exchange real property, and personal property used for business
such as fixtures and equipment, but intangibles will not qualify.
Farms and ranches also have their own unique blend of real and
personal property. For a successful Exchange, make sure that the
various assets being transferred have been identified so that
the closing statements reflect that which is being Exchanged and
that which is not.
8.
Farm and Ranch Property That Includes a Residence ... An allocation
of value must be made as to how much of the sales price relates
to the Residence and how much relates to the real estate used
for business activities. Proceeds of the sale of the Residence
(less prorated closing costs) can be disbursed directly to the
Exchanger at closing, whereas proceeds from the business property
(less prorated closing costs) must be disbursed to the Intermediary.
Recurring closing costs such as prorations of property taxes are
not considered to be closing costs. By creating a line item
for each individual closing expense the taxpayers accountant and
the IRS will be better able to determine what is taxable and what
isn't. Watch out for personal property connected with Farm
and Ranch sales, in fact you might want to drop personal property
value from the closing statement and instead show it on a Bill
of Sale which more accurately reflects the quality of what is
being sold.
9.
Multiple Units With One Unit Owner Occupied ... Similar to Farms
and Ranches, an allocation of value must be made between the Owner
Occupied unit and the rented units. Avoid showing prorated rents
and security deposits as being a debit to the seller and a credit
to the buyer on the closing statement. If this is done, the rents
and deposits will be taxable to the Exchanger because that portion
of the proceeds will be shown to have been used for operating
expenses instead of being used for non recurring closing costs
or to acquire replacement real estate as the Tax Code requires.
If the closing statement reflects a debit to the Exchanger for
these expenses (read taxable) it cannot be "fixed" at a later
date. The IRS views your closing
statement as an "indelible photograph" of the distribution of
sale proceeds in the transaction, and from this picture they will
make a call as to what is taxable and what is not. The fact that
the Exchanger may later infuse his own out of pocket capital into
the Exchange to try to offset rents and deposits will not change
the fact that the closing statement showed sale proceeds being
used for operating expenses. Ask Exchangers to pay the buyer for
rents and deposits outside of closing if possible, or at least
insist on a cashiers check from the Exchanger, made payable to
the buyer, be delivered to the title company prior to closing.
Obviously the impact of this issue is not of major importance
on the sale of a residential rental house where rents and deposits
can be measured in the hundreds of dollars, but when it comes
to a large apartment building or commercial property, the tax
consequences can be substantial.
EARNEST MONEY CONTRACT CHECKLIST
Property
Address___________________________________________________________
Sales
Price________________________________________________________________
Total
Outstanding Loans______________________________________________________
Adjusted
Basis_____________________________________________________________
{Y)
{N} Does the Contract contain an Exchange Clause?
{Y)
{N} If multiple owners, are all Exchanging?
{Y)
{N} Is the owner a trust, corporation or partnership?
{Y)
{N} Has the seller received option money?
{Y)
{N} Does the contract call for seller financing?
{Y)
{N} Any personal property identified in the contract?
{Y)
{N} Farm or ranch that includes a personal residence?
{Y)
{N} Multiple unit building that includes a residence?
{Y)
{N} Credits for deposits or pro-rated rents?
Exchange
Agreement
Every Exchange must be based on an Exchange Agreement. It is a
contract between the Exchanger and a Qualified Intermediary. In
general it states that the Exchanger agrees to transfer his old
property to the Intermediary in exchange for a new property to
be supplied by the Intermediary within 180 days. Also contained
in the contract are the terms and conditions under which this
"exchange" of properties will occur. In real life, the Intermediary
will not receive property from the Exchanger, and will not have
a property to give to the Exchanger. This situation may sound
contradictory, and it is, but the Tax Code requires the appearance
of an actual Exchange of property to be taking place in order
to qualify as a valid Exchange.
Assignment
Agreement
Most Exchanges begin with an Earnest Money Contract between a
seller and a buyer. The contract basically says that the buyer
will receive property from the seller, and the seller will receive
cash or other consideration from the buyer. To convert the
sale into an Exchange, it becomes necessary to substitute the
Intermediary as the seller of the property. This is done
because the Contract calls for the seller to receive consideration
for his property. In an Exchange, the Intermediary must receive
the consideration, not the seller. Both seller and buyer must
sign the Assignment Agreement on or before the date of closing
to approve of the substitution of the Intermediary. When we ask
a buyer to "Cooperate" in effecting a Tax Deferred Exchange, we
are asking that he or she sign an Assignment Agreement. Sometimes
an Assignment Agreement is called a Novation Agreement.
Exchange
Replacement (new) property must be identified in writing within
45 days of the close of the old property. The form must
be delivered to the Qualified Intermediary by midnight of the
45th day following the close of the relinquished property.
Failure to deliver the form on time will void the Exchange.
The properties need not be under contract to qualify as being
identified. No extensions of the 45 day time limit are allowed.
No "official" form has ever been created by the IRS or anyone
else, however the following form has been used with success for
over ten years.
Sample Identification Form
PROPERTY IDENTIFICATION FORM
It is imperative that you make a written identification of replacement
properties within 45 days of the close of the property at 16500
San Pedro, San Antonio Texas. The close date was March 27, 1998.
Identify the property you want to acquire by street address or
legal description including city, county and state in which the
property is located. If your list includes four or more properties,
you must include the fair market value of each property. You may
purchase one or more properties on the list with the following
exception. If four or more properties are identified, and the
total fair market value of all the properties is greater than
twice the contract price of the property you sold, then you must
purchase all of the properties on the list. Call us if you have
any questions regarding multiple property identification, CALL
(210) 545- 6762.
YOUR INTERMEDIARY MUST RECEIVE THIS FORM BY
May 8, 1998
Failure to deliver this form to the Intermediary by the above
date will void your Tax-Deferred Exchange We strongly recommend
that you send the form to us by registered mail so that you have
proof of the delivery date. Save a copy of the form for your records.
EXCHANGE PROPERTY MUST CLOSE ON OR BEFORE
September 20, 1998
I/we have identified the following properties as suitable exchange
properties pursuant to the Exchange Agreement by and between the
undersigned and National Exchange Services Inc.
Address or Legal Description Fair Market Value
1. ____________________________________________________________
2. ____________________________________________________________
3. ____________________________________________________________
Exchanger________________________________________Date____________
Property
Identification Rules
The Tax Code outlines the procedures for identification of replacement
properties to be purchased in a Tax Deferred Exchange The regulations
consist of three basic rules that serve to limit the number of
properties that can be identified. The rules are called the Three
Property Rule, the 200 % Rule, and the 95 % Rule, the last two
of which are based on the Fair Market Value of the properties
that are identified. Fair Market Value in this case means value
without deductions for any loans or other liabilities secured
by the property. Fair Market Value of the replacement property
is determined at the end of the 45 day identification period.
To be safe, use the asking price of the property as Fair Market
Value.
1. The Three Property Rule ... The Three Property Rule indicates
that we may identify up to three replacement properties regardless
of their Fair Market Value. If you intend to buy only one replacement
property, it still may be wise to identify one or two alternate
properties in case the first property purchase falls through.
It is not necessary to purchase all of the identified properties.
For those who are planning to identify and purchase no more than
three replacement properties, the 200 % and the 95 % Rules will
not apply.
2. The 200% Rule ... The regulations permit the identification
of more than three replacement properties but only under the following
circumstances ... The total Fair Market Value of ALL of the identified
properties must not exceed twice (200%) of the contract price
of the property sold. Exceeding the 200% limit will void the Exchange.
There is one exception to this rule, and that is…..
3. The 95% Rule ... If more than three properties have been identified
, and their total Fair Market Value exceeds 200% of the value
of what was sold, the Exchange may still be valid if … 95 % of
the total cost of all properties on the list are purchased. From
a practical point of view, it may well be said that ALL of the
listed properties must be purchased because if one of the listed
properties was not purchased, there must be at least 19 others
on the list to satisfy the 95 % Rule.
4. Avoiding The Rules ... None of the above described rules are
applicable if all of the acquisition properties are closed within
45 days of the close of your old property. It's easy to see that
by planning to acquire multiple properties, avoiding the 200%
Rule in particular could be advantageous. Wrapping up the exchange
in 45 days may seem difficult, but experience has shown us that
adequate planning before the Exchange begins can lead to a successful
close within 45 days. If Exchanging out of multiple properties,
the first property that closes will begin the 45 day identification
period.
5. How To Identify Properties ... Properties must be clearly and
accurately identified in writing and the Property Identification
Form MUST be delivered to the Intermediary by midnight of the
45th day. Deletions or substitutions of properties made during
the 45 days must also be in writing. There are NO circumstances
that will allow for an extension of the identification period.
Types
of Exchanges
Simultaneous Exchanges
Years ago the only way to effect a Tax Deferred Exchange was to
make the closing of both the old and new property occur on the
same day, or "simultaneously". This is sometimes referred to as
a "concurrent close". The problems associated with Simultaneous
Exchanges are legendary. For example, if two or more properties
need to close concurrently, but one of the closings is delayed
because of loan funding problems, is the other closing postponed?
The answer of course is yes, and this is one of the reasons that
the Tax Deferred Exchange has never been popular until recent
changes in the Tax Code have allowed for closings up to 180 days
apart. This makes life much easier for all the parties involved
and leads one to believe that anyone wishing to make a simultaneous
close must enjoy the challenge because there is no real necessity
for it. Some agents and closers still believe that a Qualified
Intermediary is not necessary when performing a Simultaneous Exchange.
The Tax Code is clear that the only "Safe Harbor" available for
a Simultaneous Exchange is the use of a Qualified Intermediary.
The logic behind the Safe Harbor is that if the Exchanger is shown
to be a principal in the closing, then he has the ability to request
Exchange proceeds from the closer. The closer, of course, having
an agency relationship with the Exchanger, must comply. This relationship
also means that the Exchanger is deemed to have had control or
"Constructive Receipt' of Exchange Proceeds during the Exchange.
If under audit the IRS can prove that the Exchanger had control
of Exchange Proceeds the Exchange would be deemed to be invalid.
Using an intermediary solves this problem because the Exchange
Agreement together with an Assignment Agreement substitutes the
Intermediary for the Exchanger as both the seller of the old property
and the buyer of the new property, with control over Exchange
Proceeds, thus becoming a principal in both closings. The substitution
effectively distances the Exchanger from the closings so that
he has no opportunity to control Exchange Proceeds. If there were
one issue that was pivotal in determining whether
an Exchange is valid it would have to be the Doctrine of Constructive
Receipt. The Tax Code is clear that an Exchanger who is shown
to control Exchange Proceeds will invalidate a Tax Deferred Exchange.
This is the primary reason that the Tax Code calls the Qualified
Intermediary a "Safe Harbor" for the prevention of constructive
or actual receipt of Exchange Proceeds.
Delayed Exchanges
Closings of the old property and the new property can be separated
in time by up to 180 days in a Delayed Exchange. Acquisition property
must be identified in writing by the 45th day of the close of
the relinquished property. A Trust Account is maintained
by the Intermediary to hold Exchange Proceeds between the sale
of the old property and the purchase of the new property. For
security purposes, Exchange Proceeds are wire transferred both
into and out of the Intermediaries Trust Account
Reverse Exchanges
The normal Exchange procedure is to first sell the old property
and then acquire a new property. As the Reverse Exchange implies,
the process is reversed in that the Exchanger first acquires the
new property, then sells the old property. The Tax Code
is not clear that Reverse Exchanges fall under the 1031 Exchange
Rules, but if properly structured as a time tested Simultaneous
Exchange, most practitioners agree that a properly structured
Reverse Exchange should survive an audit. Reverse Exchanges should
not be attempted without the help of an experienced Qualified
Intermediary. There are two basic formats for the Reverse Exchange,
both of which require that the Intermediary take title to at least
one property in the Exchange. In both cases, the Intermediary
will undertake the burdens of ownership of the property in that
he will be responsible for making mortgage payments, tax and insurance
payments, collecting rents and other obligations connected with
property ownership. From the Intermediaries perspective this is
not a job for the faint of heart. The following is a brief description
of both formats for Reverse Exchanges.
1. Intermediary Holds the New Property ... The Exchanger loans
money to the Intermediary to purchase the new property. The Intermediary
takes title to the new property and holds it until the Exchanger
sells his old property. On the same day the old property closes,
the Intermediary deeds the new property to the Exchanger. This
type of Reverse Exchange will only work if the Intermediary can
take title to the new property without having to qualify for institutional
financing on the new property. If the Intermediary can buy the
property in an all cash purchase, assume existing financing without
qualifying or initiate owner financing with the agreement of the
seller (later to be assumed by the Exchanger), this Reverse Exchange
format will be feasible. If not, the second Reverse Exchange format
can be used.
2. Intermediary Holds the Old Property...The Exchanger purchases
the new property and concurrently deeds the old property to the
Intermediary. In this case the Exchanger must put a down payment
on the new property that would approximate the amount of net cash
proceeds he would expect to receive when his old property closes.
No doubt this dollar figure would be difficult to determine until
the closing takes place, so an educated guess is in order. When
the old property sells and closed, the Intermediary deeds the
property to the buyer and passes the sale proceeds to the Exchanger.
Improvement Exchanges
An Improvement Exchange is similar to a Reverse Exchange in that
the Intermediary will take title to the new property. The difference
is that title will be held by the Intermediary while capital improvements
are made to the property. When the improvements are completed,
title will then pass to the Exchanger. Generally, the old property
will have been sold to provide funds to both purchase the new
property and make the improvements, but sometimes the Exchanger
has enough personal funds to give to the Intermediary to buy the
property and complete the construction prior to selling the old
property. In either case, the Intermediary will be on title to
the new property while the improvements are being made. An
Escrow Account will be opened by the Intermediary to facilitate
the disbursement of funds to contractors and suppliers of materials.
When construction is completed, the property will be transferred
from the Intermediary to the Exchanger.
How
To Make A Tax Deferred Exchange
Determine
if the property being sold is Like Kind. See Like Kind Property
under Basic Exchange Rules.
Contact
a Qualified Intermediary. See The Role of the Qualified Intermediary.
Locate
a purchaser for the property who will make an acceptable offer.
See The Exchange Clause under The Earnest Money Contract. Notify
the Intermediary so that he can prepare Exchange documents to
be signed at the closing.
Upon
closing, Exchange Proceeds will be wired to the Qualified Intermediaries
Trust Account. Replacement property must then be identified
in writing within 45 days. See ,Exchange Property Identification
Form and Property Identification Rules.
Make
an acceptable offer on the replacement property. See The Exchange
Clause under The Earnest Money Contract. Notify the Intermediary
so that he can prepare Exchange documents to be signed at the
closing. The Qualified Intermediary will wire transfer Exchange
Proceeds to the closer one day prior to closing.
The
Exchange is now completed. Exchanges must be reported in the tax
year that the relinquished property was closed, regardless of
the tax year the acquisition property was closed.